Domain Summary

readwise.io

grow wiser and retain books better: readwise sends you a daily email resurfacing your best highlights from kindle, instapaper, ibooks, and more.

Readwise

Global rank: #33359
Daily visitors: 50.79K
Monthly Visits: 1,523,845
Pageviews per user: 5.6
Registrar Abuse Contact Email: [email protected]
Registrant Phone:
Rating
TLD: io
IP Address: 104.26.8.37
Organization: Cloudflare, Inc.
Category: Computers Electronics and Technology >
Computers Electronics and Technology
readwise.io Icon
readwise.io
Last Status:
Online
Last Updated: 25 day ago
loading

About Website

Click here to check amazing readwise open source alternative content for United States. Otherwise, check out these important facts you probably never knew about readwise.io

grow wiser and retain books better: readwise sends you a daily email resurfacing your best highlights from kindle, instapaper, ibooks, and more.

Visit readwise.ioRight Arrow
Trust Score DNS Competitors Traffic SSL HTTP Headers WHOIS Reviews SEO

readwise.io Trust Score

readwise.io is probably legit as the trust score is reasonable. Our algorithm rated readwise.io a 98. Although our rating of readwise.io is medium to low risk, we encourage you to always vote as the evaluation of the site is done automatically.

The trust rating is high. Might be safe.
Trustscore
98 / 100

What is your feeling about readwise.io?

rating 10
rating 20
rating 30
rating 41
rating 50
4.0 / 5 Based on 1 Reviews
View/Add Comments

Which Sites are Alternatives & Competitors to readwise.io?

Explore the top alternatives and rivals of readwise.io in April 2025, and assess their data relating to website traffic, SEO, Web Server Information, and Whois. Refer to the list below for the best competitors of readwise.io, and simply click on each one to delve into their specific details.

See More

Mentioned on Their Website:

  • blog.readwise.io
    The Next Chapter of Reader: Public Beta - Readwise Blog

    https://blog.readwise.io/the-next-chapter-of-reader-public-beta/

    Daniel Doyon and Tristan Homsi | 14 Dec 2022. Today, we're excited to announce the public beta of our own, fully-integrated reading app (known as "Reader"). Get started for free at readwise.io/read. What is Reader? In case you missed our original manifesto, Reader is a more powerful, more flexible version of the classic read-it-later app.

  • help.readwise.io
    Where can I find the FAQs for Readwise Reader? - Readwise

    https://help.readwise.io/article/314-where-can-i-find-faqs-for-readwise-reader

    Here are a few ways to access the Reader FAQs document: Click this link: https://read.readwise.io/faq. Search your Reader library (keyboard shortcut / on web) for the document: On web, click the ? icon in the lower right corner, then select Help documentation: On mobile, go to your Account Settings page, scroll down, and tap View …

  • readwise.io
    Readwise Reader | Download

    https://readwise.io/read/download

    Reader for Desktop. Download for macOS (alpha, Universal) Download for Windows (alpha, x64)

  • blog.readwise.io
    Does Bionic Reading actually work? Test for yourself! - Readwise …

    https://blog.readwise.io/does-bionic-reading-actually-work/

    tl;dr As a hackathon project at our recent team offsite, Mati and I hacked together a quick experiment to test whether Bionic Reading actually works. Initial results suggest not, but there are some glimmers in the data justifying a revised experiment correcting the mistakes of our pilot study. If you have 10 minutes to read two Paul …

  • help.readwise.io
    How do I download the Readwise Chrome extension? - Readwise

    https://help.readwise.io/article/104-how-do-i-download-the-readwise-chrome-extension

    The Readwise Chrome extension is not publicly searchable in the Chrome Web Store because the extension serves no purpose without the rest of Readwise configured, which disqualifies it from being publicly featured on the store.

  • help.readwise.io
    How do I invite my friends to Readwise? - Readwise

    https://help.readwise.io/article/54-how-do-i-invite-my-friends-to-readwise

    While you're in your free trial period, you can use your personal invite link to get both you and your friend an extra free month of Readwise! Right now, the invite bonus only adds free months for those users in trial. That said, your friends will still get the free months even if you use the invite link after you've subscribed.

  • webcatalog.io
    Readwise - Desktop App for Mac, Windows (PC), Linux

    https://webcatalog.io/en/apps/readwise/

    Download WebCatalog Desktop. Website: readwise.io. Enhance your experience with the desktop app for Readwise on WebCatalog Desktop for Mac, Windows, Linux. Run apps in distraction-free windows with many enhancements. Manage and switch between multiple accounts and apps easily without switching browsers. Readwise helps you get the most …

  • github.com
    Telegram Bot for ReadWise - GitHub

    https://github.com/ixnet/readwise_telegram_bot

    Security considerations. To make this bot work you have to provide to the bot ReadWise API token. Because I don't want to store your tokens, you have to set up a separate bot for yourself. From my perspective Telegram Bot API doesn't provide secure way to store sensitive data, that is why you have to create your own bot.

  • simonhsu.github.io
    一個透過騙大腦來記起許多重點的筆記串接神器 - readwise

    https://simonhsu.github.io/post/readwise/

    寫筆記時同步記錄出處,相關資訊全都幫你寫回筆記軟體. 電腦網頁透過安裝 chrome extention 外掛程式 ( hypothesis / readwise community ) 手機安裝 readwise app ,看到想記重點的部分就反白,指定分享到 readwise app ,. 只要預先設定好,有寫上筆記的,透過搜索在你的最終 ...

  • readwise.io
    Readwise Apps | Readwise

    https://readwise.io/homescreen

    Readwise helps thousands of readers get the most out of their digital highlights. Grow wiser and retain books better: Readwise sends you a daily email resurfacing your best highlights from Kindle, Instapaper, iBooks, and more.

  • help.readwise.io
    Apple Books - Readwise

    https://help.readwise.io/category/36-apple-books

    Apple Books. How do I import Apple Books highlights from my iPhone/iPad? How do I import highlights by emailing them to Readwise? How do I import highlights from Apple Books? Can I import highlights from PDFs read in Apple Books? What do I do if the Mac tool isn't importing my Apple Book highlights? Frequently asked questions about Readwise.

  • readwise.io
    Pricing | Readwise

    https://readwise.io/pricing/reader

    Start 30 day free trial. Readwise (includes Reader) $9.99/mo billed annually ($12.99 billed monthly) All features in Reader. Lock in low price for life. All features in Readwise. Import your entire highlight library from other sources. Organize your highlights with tags & notes. Export your highlights to Notion, Obsidian, and more.

  • readwise.io
    Divorced, Disheveled and Hiking Toward Love | annotated by David

    https://readwise.io/reader/shared/01j0hqq09y2a0x04f5hg8ry25w/

    Annotated by David Kanigan. In David Nicholls’s “You Are Here,” a boggy trek through the English countryside becomes an unlikely impetus for midlife romance. …

  • blog.readwise.io
    Does Bionic Reading actually work? We timed over 2,000 …

    https://blog.readwise.io/bionic-reading-results/

    9 Jul 2022. tl;dr. Actually no, the results will probably not surprise you. After analyzing data from 2,074 testers, we found no evidence that Bionic Reading has any positive effect on reading speed. In fact, participants read 2.6 words per minute slower on average with Bionic Reading than without. That said, the difference here is so small ...

  • techforword.com
    9 ways to use Artificial Intelligence in Readwise Reader

    https://www.techforword.com/blog/9-ways-use-artificial-intelligence-readwise-reader-prepare-translation-interpreting-assignments

    First, import web pages, documents, PDFs, or videos by going to read.readwise.io, then clicking the ‘+’ button in the lower-left corner and either “Add a URL” or “Upload a file.” Even faster, install the Chrome, Firefox, or Safari extensions, and import documents with a single click.

  • help.readwise.io
    Amazon Kindle - Readwise

    https://help.readwise.io/category/33-kindle

    Can I jump to a highlight directly in the Kindle app? How does the Readwise sync with Goodreads work? Does Readwise have access to my Amazon password? Can I sync a second Kindle account with Readwise? How do I import Kindle highlights from an international Amazon domain? Frequently asked questions about Readwise.

  • roxinekee.com
    Readwise 101: Get Notes & Highlights from Pocket, Instapaper, & Kindle

    https://www.roxinekee.com/blog/readwise

    DM the tweet to @readwise.io, along with any notes or comments you have (I prefer this latter method because it’s less intrusive.) Saving tweetstorms is similar. You can either. Reply “@readwiseio save thread” to the last tweet in the thread. DM the thread to @readwise.io with “thread” or "t" in the message. How to Save Book Highlights

  • help.readwise.io
    Frequently Asked (FAQs) - Readwise

    https://help.readwise.io/collection/1-frequently-asked-faqs

    How do I save highlights from the podcasts I listen to using Airr? How does the Readwise to Obsidian export integration work? How much does Readwise cost after the free trial? What highlight sources does Readwise support? How do I import highlights from physical or paper books? Frequently asked questions about Readwise.

  • readwise.io
    Readwise Reader | The first read-it-later app built for power readers

    https://readwise.io/reader

    Reader is built API-first: roll your own solutions and integrate your tools using our API. Easy consistent review with Readwise. Reader automatically syncs to Readwise: making it easy to revisit and learn from your highlights with Daily Review.

  • readwise.io
    Import your iBooks highlights | Readwise

    https://readwise.io/ibooks

    Import your iBooks highlights. Just download and run the mac program on your computer. Have questions? [email protected]. Readwise helps thousands of readers get the most out of their digital highlights. Grow wiser and retain books better: Readwise sends you a daily email resurfacing your best highlights from Kindle, Instapaper, iBooks, and …

  • securedpackets.com
    How I use Readwise.io and Obsidian for note workflow

    https://securedpackets.com/how-i-use-readwise-and-obsidian-for-my-note-workflow/

    I’ve really enjoyed Readwise.io, and for that reason I feel solid products like Readwise could use (reasonable) financial support to stay available and feature-rich. Another feature of Readwise which I find helpful is the ability to display random highlighted content on a daily basis, almost like digital flash cards. I use this feature when ...

  • bookcision.readwise.io
    Bookcision | bookcision

    https://bookcision.readwise.io/

    Bump the version number of Bookcision in package.json. Run grunt build. Copy dest/bookcision.js to dist/bookcision.js (replacing the old version) That’s it! The new version will be at dist/bookcision.js and automatically updated via Github’s CDN as soon as the change is merged into master. The bookcision website (where you install the ...

  • notion-marketplace.com
    Readwise | Notion integration | Notion Marketplace

    https://www.notion-marketplace.com/integrations/readwise

    Readwise fixes this using a scientific process called Spaced Repetition. We surface your best highlights back to you at the right times, and let you review them every day with the daily email and app. Tag, note, search, and organize. With your highlights all in one place, Readwise gives you the power to organize and connect these ideas in new ways.

  • play.google.com
    Readwise Reader - Apps on Google Play

    https://play.google.com/store/apps/details/Readwise_Reader?id=com.readermobile&hl=en_US

    Email us at [email protected] or use in the in-app feedback mechanism. Updated on. Jun 14, 2024. Productivity. Data safety. arrow_forward. Safety starts with understanding how developers collect and share your data. Data privacy and security practices may vary based on your use, region, and age. The developer provided this information and may ...

  • coupons.hotdeals.com
    15% OFF Readwise Promo Codes & Coupons - June 2024

    https://coupons.hotdeals.com/store/readwise-promo-code

    Limited Time: 50% Off Sale. May 2, 2024. 13 used. Get Code. MN50. See Details. Saving money can be so easy if you use Limited time: 50% off sale. Popular items may be out of stock soon. Also, more valid Readwise Promo Codes are waiting for you at readwise.io.

  • blog.readwise.io
    Readwise Blog

    https://blog.readwise.io/

    Today, we're excited to announce the public beta of our own, fully-integrated reading app (known as "Reader"). Get started for free at readwise.io/read. What is …

  • help.readwise.io
    How do I get started with Reader? - Readwise

    https://help.readwise.io/article/163-how-do-i-get-started-with-reader

    Reader is a cross-platform reading application which includes a web app (read.readwise.io), mobile apps for iOS and Android, and browser extensions for Chrome, Chromium-based browsers (Edge, Brave, Arc, etc), Firefox, and Safari.The best way to get started using Reader is to navigate to read.readwise.io and read the Getting Started …

  • blog.readwise.io
    Reader: Frequently Asked Questions - Readwise Blog

    https://blog.readwise.io/p/f8c0f71c-fe5f-4025-af57-f9f65c53fed7/

    Reader is a cross-platform reading application which includes a web app ( read.readwise.io ), mobile apps for iOS and Android, and browser extensions for …

See More

DNS Lookup

DNS entries, such as A, NS, MX, and TXT records, are crucial for the functioning of the Internet. The A record maps a domain name to an IPv4 address, while the NS record specifies authoritative name servers for a domain. The MX record identifies the mail server responsible for receiving email messages for a domain. Additionally, the TXT record allows for the association of any text information with a domain name. These records play a vital role in ensuring proper communication and connectivity across the internet.

HostClassTTLTypeData
readwise.ioIN300Aip: 104.26.9.37
readwise.ioIN300Aip: 104.26.8.37
readwise.ioIN300Aip: 172.67.69.113
readwise.ioIN3600NStarget: cory.ns.cloudflare.com
readwise.ioIN3600NStarget: ines.ns.cloudflare.com
readwise.ioIN1800SOAmname: cory.ns.cloudflare.comrname: dns.cloudflare.comserial: 2341881326refresh: 10000retry: 2400expire: 604800minimum-ttl: 1800
readwise.ioIN300MXtarget: alt2.aspmx.l.google.compri: 5
readwise.ioIN300MXtarget: aspmx3.googlemail.compri: 10
readwise.ioIN300MXtarget: alt1.aspmx.l.google.compri: 5
readwise.ioIN300MXtarget: aspmx.l.google.compri: 1
readwise.ioIN300MXtarget: aspmx2.googlemail.compri: 10
readwise.ioIN300TXTtxt: v=spf1 a mx include:helpscoutemail.com include:_spf.google.com ~all
readwise.ioIN300TXTtxt: google-site-verification=ABiKSFlHNxUfwI5JOFykth2ygQOEMiJ3osZ3fNWBm8U
readwise.ioIN300TXTtxt: google-site-verification=iS7iy4KrUrmoe7nVdj7OOCerNSzkJ4hKvZLeq7wJjj0
readwise.ioIN300AAAA
readwise.ioIN300AAAA
readwise.ioIN300AAAA

readwise.io Traffic Analysis

According to global rankings, readwise.io holds the position of #33359. It attracts an approximate daily audience of 50.79K visitors, leading to a total of 50907 pageviews. On a monthly basis, the website garners around 1523.85K visitors.

Daily Visitors50.79K
Monthly Visits1523.85K
Pages per Visit5.6
Visit Duration0:05:13
Bounce Rate40.8%
Want complete report?Full SEMrush Report >>
Daily Unique Visitors:
50794
Monthly Visits:
1523845
Pages per Visit:
5.6
Daily Pageviews:
50907
Avg. visit duration:
0:05:13
Bounce rate:
40.8%
Monthly Visits (SEMrush):
1526301

Traffic Sources

SourcesTraffic Share
Social:
2.51%
Paid Referrals:
2.79%
Mail:
1.53%
Search:
9.77%
Direct:
83.36%

Visitors by Country

CountryTraffic Share
United States:
33.03%
China:
7.44%
Taiwan:
4.86%
Hong Kong:
4.15%
France:
3.86%

SSL Checker - SSL Certificate Verify

An SSL certificate is a digital certificate that ensures a secure encrypted connection between a web server and a user's browser. It provides authentication and encryption to keep data private and protected during transmission. readwise.io supports HTTPS, demonstrating their commitment to providing a secure browsing experience for users.

name
readwise.io
hash
e571490a
issuer
Let's Encrypt
version
2
serialNumber
382748371862305598952110675996438584666361
validFrom_time_t
1716365620
validTo_time_t
1724141619
signatureTypeSN
ecdsa-with-SHA384
signatureTypeLN
ecdsa-with-SHA384
signatureTypeNID
795
keyUsage
Digital Signature
extendedKeyUsage
TLS Web Server Authentication, TLS Web Client Authentication
basicConstraints
CA:FALSE
subjectKeyIdentifier
6C:80:EC:EC:B1:48:C9:A8:D5:60:F4:64:19:57:D4:77:5B:33:82:9A
authorityKeyIdentifier
keyid:5A:F3:ED:2B:FC:36:C2:37:79:B9:52:30:EA:54:6F:CF:55:CB:2E:AC
authorityInfoAccess
OCSP - URI:http://e1.o.lencr.org CA Issuers - URI:http://e1.i.lencr.org/
subjectAltName
DNS:imgproxy.readwise.io, DNS:readwise.io
certificatePolicies
Policy: 2.23.140.1.2.1

HTTP Headers

HTTP headers are additional segments of data exchanged between a client (e.g. a web browser) and a server during an HTTP request or response. They serve to provide instructions, metadata, or control parameters for the interaction between the client and server.

Status
HTTP/1.1 200 OK
Date
Wed, 29 May 2024 03:09:14 GMT
Content-Type
text/html; charset=utf-8
Content-Length
108656
Connection
keep-alive
Report-To
{"group":"heroku-nel","max_age":3600,"endpoints":[{"url":"https://nel.heroku.com/reports?ts=1716952154&sid=e11707d5-02a7-43ef-b45e-2cf4d2036f7d&s=GUxRBLqdWUp9XOlTXXMPSpXYZcwrfFCXtphnZrHolWk%3D"}]}
Reporting-Endpoints
heroku-nel=https://nel.heroku.com/reports?ts=1716952154&sid=e11707d5-02a7-43ef-b45e-2cf4d2036f7d&s=GUxRBLqdWUp9XOlTXXMPSpXYZcwrfFCXtphnZrHolWk%3D
Nel
{"report_to":"heroku-nel","max_age":3600,"success_fraction":0.005,"failure_fraction":0.05,"response_headers":["Via"]}
Version
83cbb79fb0ae4c2cbcb151f600f56d19af6b8808
X-Frame-Options
DENY
Vary
Cookie, Origin
X-Content-Type-Options
nosniff
Referrer-Policy
same-origin
Set-Cookie
csrftoken=PnOUVL3xLHz11e6qt4OutQsnckE4sY4BahWFJab4HwV8KGAZiXDS2uTP24JiBQKP; expires=Wed, 28 May 2025 03:09:14 GMT; Max-Age=31449600; Path=/; SameSite=Lax; Secure
Via
1.1 vegur
CF-Cache-Status
DYNAMIC
Server
cloudflare
CF-RAY
88b348d599d5aaa9-SJC

Where is readwise.io hosted?

readwise.io is likely hosted in various data centers located across different regions worldwide. The current data center mentioned is just one of many where the website may be hosted.

Whois Information

WHOIS protocol used to get domain/IP info. Common for reg details, ownership of a domain/IP. Check readwise.io for reg/admin contact info, owner, org, email, phone, creation, and expiration dates.

Domain Updated Date:2023-08-03
Domain Created Date:2017-08-28
Domain Expiry Date:
Domain Name:
Registrar WHOIS Server:whois.namecheap.com
Registrar Abuse Contact Email:[email protected]
Registrar Abuse Contact Phone:+1.9854014545
Domain Registrar:NameCheap, Inc.
Domain Owner:Privacy service provided by Withheld for Privacy ehf

Domain Name: readwise.io

Registry Domain ID: 954e64903e2e422cb969628354b88a8e-DONUTS

Registrar WHOIS Server: whois.namecheap.com

Registrar URL: https://www.namecheap.com/

Updated Date: 2023-08-03T07:25:34Z

Creation Date: 2017-08-28T17:18:28Z

Registry Expiry Date: 2024-08-28T17:18:28Z

Registrar: NameCheap, Inc.

Registrar IANA ID: 1068

Registrar Abuse Contact Email: [email protected]

Registrar Abuse Contact Phone: +1.9854014545

Registrant Organization: Privacy service provided by Withheld for Privacy ehf

Registrant State/Province: Capital Region

Registrant Country: IS

Name Server: ines.ns.cloudflare.com

SEO Analysis

SEO analysis involves examining the performance of a website, including titles, descriptions, keywords, and website speed. It also includes identifying popular keywords and researching competitor websites to understand their strategies. The analysis aims to optimize the website's visibility and improve its ranking on search engines.

Title Tag:
Readwise

Length: 8 characters

Title tags are usually best kept short, within 50-70 characters. It's important to note that search engines will typically read the entire title tag even if it exceeds 70 characters, but there is a chance they may cut it off or disregard it.

Meta Description:
Grow wiser and retain books better Readwise sends you a daily email resurfacing your best highlights from Kindle, Instapaper, iBooks, and more.

Length: 143 characters

When crafting website descriptions, keep in mind that search engines only show the first 150-160 characters in search results. To ensure your entire description is visible, aim for a length of 25-160 characters. If your description is too long, it may get cut off. Conversely, if it's too short, search engines may add text from elsewhere on your page. Additionally, search engines may modify the description you provide to better match the user's search intent. It's best to strike a balance between brevity and relevance for optimal visibility.

Meta Keywords:

No meta keywords found.

In the realm of search engine optimization, the meta keywords tag has become a relic of the past due to its potential for misuse, ultimately leading major search engines to disregard it in their ranking algorithms.

Keywords Cloud:
Term Count Density
readwise 15 7.85%
sign 8 4.19%
highlights 8 4.19%
email 6 3.14%
read 4 2.09%
reading 4 2.09%
free 4 2.09%
time 3 1.57%
remember 3 1.57%
ideas 2 1.05%
liberate 2 1.05%
terms 2 1.05%
invite 2 1.05%
place 2 1.05%
sync 2 1.05%
search 2 1.05%
organize 2 1.05%
connect 2 1.05%
tag 2 1.05%
retain 2 1.05%
favorite 2 1.05%
times 2 1.05%
note-taking 2 1.05%
started 2 1.05%
days 2 1.05%
password 2 1.05%
app 2 1.05%
amazon 2 1.05%
revisit 2 1.05%

A crucial factor in search engine optimization is keyword density, which refers to the proportion of a particular keyword present in the text of a webpage. In order to achieve high rankings on search engine results pages, it is essential to maintain the appropriate keyword density for your primary keyword.

Headings:
<H1>
3
<H2>
10
<H3>
0
<H4>
3
<H5>
1
<H6>
2
<h1>Here's what our users say:</h1>
<h1>Here's how Readwise works:</h1>
<h1>Get the most out of what you read</h1>
<h2>Sync to your favorite note-taking apps</h2>
<h2>Revisit your highlights</h2>
<h2>Remember</h2>
<h2>Remember what you read</h2>
<h2>Review</h2>
<h2>Readwise makes it easy to revisit and learn from your ebook & article highlights. </h2>
<h2>Import Highlights</h2>
<h2>Get More Time</h2>
<h2>Tag, note, search, and organize</h2>
<h2>Start reading with superpowers</h2>
<h4>Recall more and grow your knowledge over time.</h4>
<h4>Sync your highlights from Kindle, Instapaper, Pocket, iBooks, and more.</h4>
<h4>Review the best parts easily through a daily email & app.</h4>
<h5> or </h5>
<h6> or </h6>
<h6> or </h6>

In SEO, the primary focus is placed on keywords within the content. The title of the page holds the highest importance, followed by heading tags such as h1, h2, and h3. The h1 heading should be the largest on the page, while the h2 heading should be slightly smaller, and the h3 heading even smaller. This hierarchical structure is crucial for optimizing search engine rankings.

Image Alt Attribute:
72 images found in your page, and 31 images are without "ALT" text.

What is the issue about?
The tag does not have an ALT attribute defined. As a general rule, search engines do not interpret the content of image files. The text provided in the attribute enables the site owner to provide relevant information to the search engine and to the end user. Alt text is helpful to end users if they have images disabled or if the image does not properly load. In addition, the Alt text is utilized by screen readers. Make sure that your Alt text is descriptive and accurately reflects what the image represents and supports the content on the page.

How to fix?
Use the <img alt> attribute to write descriptive content for the image: <img source='pic.gif' alt='Accurate and descriptive keyword text that represents the image.' />.

Top Organic Search Terms:
Term Search Volume Traffic Traffic (%)
readwise open source alternative 40 0 0%

CO-Hosted

CoHosted refers to a situation where multiple domain names (websites) are using the same IP address to point to their respective web servers. They could be owned by different individuals or organizations and may serve entirely different purposes.

mangabat.com
readwise.io

People reviews about readwise.io

Very positive reviews

rating 5

Total reviews: 2
Average score: 5 stars

The total score is based on reviews found on the following sites
Scamadviser: 5/5 stars, 2 reviews

Add your review

rating 1 rating 2 rating 3 rating 4 rating 5

Very positive reviews

rating 5

Total reviews: 2
Average score: 5 stars

The total score is based on reviews found on the following sites
Scamadviser: 5/5 stars, 2 reviews


Back Top
Feedback